Assignment X: Online Debate (XX%)
Description
Debates are an effective and lively way to help see more than one side of an issue, and a chance to practice persuasive and concise writing.
Part 1: You will work in small groups to prepare a compelling and persuasive argument on one side of an issue. Your group will post a short position paper to a discussion topic.
Part 2: Next, your group will be asked to prepare a rebuttal to another group’s position paper, in the same format.
Please refer to the rubric at the end of this document for evaluation details.
Note: A Peer & Self Evaluation is to be completed following the submission of your group work. While Peer & Self Evaluation is graded separately from the Online Debate, you need to know the following:
-
Group members typically all receive the same grade for their Online Debate activity
-
If through the Peer & Self Evaluation, it is deemed that you did not participate in your group work, you may receive a zero for both for the Peer & Self Evaluation and the Online Debate assignment.
Instructions
Groups are given their own private LEARN discussion topic to facilitate carrying out group tasks.
-
Get Organized
Get to know your debate team: Group membership can be viewed by clicking Connect and then Groups on the course navigation bar above. If you are not in a group by the date indicated in the Course Schedule, please contact Technical Support at learnhelp@uwaterloo.ca. Technical support is available during regular business hours, Monday to Friday, 8:30 AM to 4:30 PM (Eastern Time).
- Introduce yourself to your group members
- Determine roles and responsibilities for group members
- Start Working
- Connect to discuss the topic and brainstorm ideas for your paper.
- Share research results. Remember to use credible information sources and respect copyright.
- Author a position paper following the information listed in the Requirements section.
- Make sure you have a persuasive argument and support your position with research.
- Repeat the process for your rebuttal position paper.
How you will be evaluated
- Each position paper (your initial post and your rebuttal) should be no more than 500 words (not including references). The word limit is strict – the best papers are also the most concise.
- The post must consistently follow APA style.
- For help with APA style, visit the OWL – Purdue’s Online Writing Lab.
- Each paper is graded out of 16 points using the following rubric and together they are worth XX% of your final grade.
- Learners may receive partial scores or a zero for unacceptable contribution to the group’s work.
Persuasiveness |
The group shows an inadequate understanding of the topic.
The argument is not convincing.
|
The group shows a partial understanding of the topic, but arguments are flawed or unsubstantiated. |
The group shows an understanding of the topic and adequately presented their argument. |
The group shows an in-depth understanding of the topic and presents a compelling argument. |
4 |
Research |
Points are unsupported and reliant on conjecture. |
Some points are supported with facts, statistics, and/or examples; relevance is questionable. |
Points are adequately supported with relevant facts, statistics, and/or examples. |
Demonstrates exceptional, broad, and in-depth research with relevant facts, statistics, and/or examples. |
4 |
Organization |
The organization is unclear and/or difficult to follow. The word limit is not adhered to. |
Arguments are partially organized in a logical fashion. The word limit is not adhered to. |
Arguments are organized in a logical fashion. The word limit is adhered to. |
Arguments flow logically from one idea to the next. The organization enhances the argument. The word limit is adhered to. |
4 |
APA Style |
APA style is followed a few times in the document. No sources or mostly not cited in APA. |
APA style is followed sometimes in the document. Some sources are missing (or not cited in APA). |
Most of the document follows APA style. Most sources are cited in APA with few errors. |
The entire document follows APA formatting and all sources are properly cited in APA. |
4 |
How to Submit Your Discussions
Discussions can be accessed by going to Connect and then Discussions on the course navigation bar above. Each assigned discussion will have a specific topic (e.g., "Discussion 1") that will only be available on the dates indicated in the Course Schedule.
If You Need Technical Help
-
Read the Waterloo LEARN Help: Discussions documentation.
-
If you encounter technical difficulty, please contact Technical Support at learnhelp@uwaterloo.ca. Technical support is available during regular business hours, Monday to Friday, 8:30 AM to 4:30 PM (Eastern Time).
Online Debate framework adapted from University of Calgary Continuing Education.
Return to Remote Teaching: Seminars and Discussion-based Courses